The popular cooking show MasterChef has returned to TV screens with a new series, despite the recent sacking of its hosts, Gregg Wallace and John Torode. The BBC decided to air the series, which was filmed before the pair’s dismissal, citing it as “the right thing to do” for the chefs who participated. However, this decision has sparked controversy, with some groups criticizing the network for rewarding “bad behavior” with prime-time coverage.
Broadcast union Bectu has expressed concerns that airing the series could trigger freelancers whose complaints against Wallace and Torode were upheld. A leading women’s rights charity also warned that many people would feel “deeply uncomfortable” watching the show. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy shared her personal stance, stating she wouldn’t watch the show, but emphasized that it’s not her place to dictate what broadcasters can or can’t show.
The new series features Wallace and Torode, but with noticeable changes. There are fewer jokes and less banter between the hosts and contestants. TV critic Scott Bryan noted that the hosts’ role has been reduced, focusing more on explaining challenges and reviewing food rather than entertaining the audience. One contestant, Sarah Shafi, was edited out after requesting the series not be broadcast, citing respect for those who made complaints against the hosts.
The controversy surrounding MasterChef began with allegations of misconduct against Wallace, which led to an investigation by the show’s production company, Banijay. The report revealed over 40 upheld complaints against Wallace, including unwelcome physical contact and being in a state of undress. Torode faced criticism for using a severely offensive racist term on set in 2018. Both hosts were subsequently fired, with the BBC stating that the decision to air the series doesn’t diminish their view of the seriousness of the upheld findings.
The BBC defended its decision to air the series, emphasizing its commitment to recognizing the chefs’ hard work and dedication. The network also highlighted the importance of giving audiences the choice to watch the series. Meanwhile, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy praised the BBC for signing up to a new watchdog designed to improve standards in the creative industries, urging others to follow suit. The controversy surrounding MasterChef raises questions about the future of the show and the impact of the hosts’ dismissal on its reputation.
